Comparative Analysis of Frame Strength in a Drum Brake Testing Device Using Welded and Bolted Joints Through Solidworks 2020 Simulation
Keywords:
Solidworks, Welded Joints, Bolted Joints, Structural Simulation, Drum Brake Testing Device, Frame StrengthAbstract
This study investigates the comparative structural strength of frame constructions used in a drum brake testing device, focusing on two different joint types: welded and bolted connections. The analysis was conducted using SolidWorks 2020 (Javelin Technologies, 2023), employing its Simulation feature to evaluate structural performance under load conditions. Both frame models were designed with identical dimensions and materials to ensure a fair comparison. The evaluation centered on three key parameters: maximum stress, total deformation, and safety factor. Simulation results demonstrated significant performance differences between the two joint types. Welded joints exhibited more uniform stress distribution (Verma et al., 2025) and lower deformation, suggesting superior strength and stability over bolted joints in this application (Menara Ilmu, 2021; Furqani, 2022). These findings contribute valuable insights for engineers and designers in selecting optimal joint methods for the construction of brake testing equipment.
References
Artizono. (2025). Bolted vs Welded Connections: A Comprehensive Comparison. Diakses dari https://artizono.com/bolted-vs-welded-connections-a-comprehensive-comparison/
NY Engineers. (2025). Structural Engineering: Welded vs. Bolted Connections. Diakses dari https://www.ny-engineers.com/blog/structural-engineering-comparing-welded-and-bolted-unions
MachineMFG. (2024). Choosing Between Bolted and Welded Connections: A Comparative Study. Diakses dari https://www.machinemfg.com/bolted-and-welded-connections/
MachineMFG. (2025). Welding vs Bolting: A Comprehensive Comparison for Structural Applications. Diakses dari https://shop.machinemfg.com/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-welding-over-bolting/
LRKD Industries. (2025). Bolted vs. Welded Connections: Which is Better for Structural Integrity?. Diakses dari https://lrkdindustries.com/blogs/news/bolted-vs-welded-connections-which-is-better-for-structural-integrity
Stellar Structures. (2025). Steel Structure Connections: Welded and Bolted Connection Design and Their Differences. Diakses dari https://structures.com.sg/steel-structure-connections-welded-and-bolted-connection-design-and-their-differences/
Construction HQ. (2025). Structural Engineering: Comparing Welded and Bolted Unions. Diakses dari https://www.constructionhq.world/issue-sections/building-equipment-products/metal-steel/structural-engineering-comparing-welded-and-bolted-unions/
Verma, N. et al. (2025). Comparative Study on Bolted, Riveted, and Welded Connections – A Review. Diakses dari https://www.ijmrt.in/papers/Nidhi_Verma_et_al_V7I4002.pdf
Hagiwara, I. et al. (2006). Finite Element Analysis and Modeling of Structure with Bolted Joints. Diakses dari https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0307904X0600062X
Pawar, G. B., & Waghmode, L. Y. (2016). Analysis of Bolted Joints with Different Bolt Patterns Using Non-Linear Finite Element Analysis. Diakses dari https://www.ijert.org/research/analysis-of-bolted-joints-with-different-bolt-patterns-using-non-linear-finite-element-analysis-IJERTV3IS10958.pdf
Srinivasan, G., & Lehnhoff, T. F. (2015). Techniques for Design of Bolted Joint in Finite Element Analysis. Diakses dari https://www.ijste.org/articles/IJSTEV2I2061.pdf
WSEAS. (2023). Modern Methods for Modelling Bolted Joints at the Assembly Stage: A Systematic Review. Diakses dari https://wseas.com/journals/ew/2023/a22engw-008%282023%29.pdf
Academia.edu. (2025). Finite Element Analysis of Bolted Joint. Diakses dari https://www.academia.edu/74180470/Finite_Element_Analysis_of_Bolted_Joint
DiVA Portal. (2012). FE-modeling of Bolted Joints in Structures. Diakses dari https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2%3A550529/fulltext01
ScienceDirect. (2017). Finite Element Modeling for Structural Dynamic Analysis of Bolted Joints. Diakses dari https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1877705817336470
GrabCAD. (2024). Simulate Preloaded Bolted Joint with SolidWorks Simulation. Diakses dari https://grabcad.com/tutorials/simulate-preloaded-bolted-joint-with-solidworks-simulation
SlideShare. (2016). SolidWorks Simulation Bolted Assembly. Diakses dari https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/solid-works-simulation-bolted-assembly/61961498
Javelin Technologies. (2023). Simulate Welding in SOLIDWORKS with Weld Edge Simulation. Diakses dari https://www.javelin-tech.com/blog/2023/04/simulate-welding-in-solidworks-with-weld-edge-simulation/
Engineering Science. (2016). Modeling of Single-Fillet Lap Joint in SolidWorks Simulation. Diakses dari https://www.engineeringscience.rs/images/pdf/doi10.5937jaes14-8900.pdf
SolidWorks Forum. (2014). Best Practice for Modeling Bolts Instead of Using. Diakses dari https://forum.solidworks.com/thread/89724
The World Material. (2025). SAE AISI 1020 Steel Properties, C1020 Carbon Steel Yield Strength. Diakses dari https://www.theworldmaterial.com/astm-sae-aisi-1020-carbon-steel/
Artizono. (2025). SAE AISI 1020: Properties, Uses, and Composition. Diakses dari https://artizono.com/sae-aisi-1020-properties-uses-and-composition/
Matmake. (2025). SAE/AISI 1020 Carbon Steel - Composition and Properties. Diakses dari https://matmake.com/materials-data/steel-1020-properties.html
Dawang Metals. (2024). AISI 1020 Carbon Steel: Properties, Equivalents, Applications, Benefits, and Limitations. Diakses dari https://dawangmetals.com/materials/1020-carbon-steel/
Material Welding. (2023). AISI 1020 Steel Properties. Diakses dari https://materialwelding.com/aisi-1020-steel-properties/
Steel Grades. (2025). Datasheet for Steel Grades Carbon Steel AISI 1020. Diakses dari https://steel-grades.com/Steel-Grades/Carbon-Steel/18/6224/_AISI___1020.pdf
MachineMFG. (2025). Comprehensive Guide to SAE AISI 1020 Steel Properties. Diakses dari https://shop.machinemfg.com/comprehensive-guide-to-sae-aisi-1020-steel-properties/
IJAMTES. (2017). Design and Analysis of Drum Brake. Diakses dari https://www.ijamtes.org/gallery/ijamtes%20krest%20217.pdf
DocsLib. (2025). Design and Analysis of Drum Brake. Diakses dari https://docslib.org/doc/6178084/design-and-analysis-of-drum-brake
IJSRED. (2024). Design and Analysis of Drum Brake. Diakses dari https://ijsred.com/volume7/issue6/IJSRED-V7I6P45.pdf
Muchlisinalahuddin. (2021). Analisis Pengaruh Kelurusan Poros Kopling Pompa Hidraulik Terhadap Variasi Tekanan Pada PLTA Maninjau. *Rang Teknik Journal*, 4(2), 359–364.
Muchlisinalahuddin, Riza Muharni, Ridwan Maulana, & Ikhsan. (2023). Analisa Pengaruh Beban terhadap Alat Uji Sistem Pengereman Tromol melalui Parameter Tekanan Rem Menggunakan Mesin TYE Robot GX 160. *Jurnal Ilmiah Poli Rekayasa*, 19(1), 35–40.
Wardianto, D., Anwar, I., & Muchlisinalahuddin. (2021). Aplikasi Kinematika pada Mekanisme Lengan Penanam Alat Tanam Padi Semi Mekanis. Menara Ilmu, Vol. XV No. 2. ISSN 1693-2617. LPPM UMSB.
Furqani, I. (2022). Analisis Kekuatan Rangka Mesin Perontok Padi Menggunakan SolidWorks 2019. Skripsi. Universitas Muhammadiyah Sumatera Barat.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Thariq Abdul Azis, Muchlisinalahuddin, Riza Muharni (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
